Clean Gutter Protection Logo
(888) 507-4854
Back To Blog
Gutter Replacement Guide: Repair vs Replace in 2026

Gutter Replacement Guide: Repair vs Replace in 2026

Complete guide to gutter replacement decisions. Learn when to repair vs replace, material costs, and Florida-specific requirements from experienced contractors.

By Clean Gutter Protection
Share:
Gutter Installation

Key Takeaways:

  • Gutters older than 20 years typically need replacement, not repair
  • Multiple leaks, sagging sections, or foundation water damage indicate replacement time
  • Aluminum gutters cost $4-8/ft installed; copper runs $15-25/ft in Jacksonville
  • Florida building codes require specific wind ratings and corrosion resistance
  • Hurricane season planning affects timing and material choices significantly
  • Professional assessment saves money by catching problems before they become expensive

Every homeowner faces this decision eventually: spend money patching up old gutters or invest in a complete replacement system. After installing and repairing thousands of gutter systems across Jacksonville, I can tell you that most homeowners wait too long to replace and end up paying far more in water damage than they would have spent on new gutters.

Here's how to make the right decision for your home and budget.

When Repair Makes Sense

Minor Issues Worth Fixing

Small leaks at joints:

  • Cost to repair: $50-150 per joint
  • When it makes sense: Gutters under 10 years old with isolated problems
  • DIY possibility: Yes, with proper sealants and techniques

Loose gutter hangers:

  • Cost to repair: $25-75 per hanger
  • When it makes sense: Storm damage or normal settling issues
  • DIY possibility: Yes, but requires proper fastener selection

Clogged or damaged downspouts:

  • Cost to repair: $75-200 per downspout
  • When it makes sense: Downspouts in good condition with localized clogs
  • DIY possibility: Partial - unclogging yes, replacement no

Minor sagging (less than 1 inch):

  • Cost to repair: $100-300 per section
  • When it makes sense: Isolated problem with otherwise sound gutters
  • DIY possibility: No - requires proper pitch adjustment

Florida-Specific Repair Considerations

Salt air damage:

  • Surface corrosion can be treated with marine-grade coatings
  • Deep pitting requires replacement
  • Cost of coating: $2-4 per linear foot

Hurricane damage assessment:

  • Small dents and dings: Repairable if function isn't affected
  • Bent or twisted sections: Usually require replacement
  • Loose from house: May indicate structural issues requiring replacement

Clear Signs You Need Replacement

Age-Related Replacement Triggers

Gutters over 20 years old are living on borrowed time, regardless of apparent condition. Here's why:

  • Fastener holes have enlarged from thermal expansion cycles
  • Protective coatings have deteriorated
  • Metal fatigue makes them vulnerable to storm damage
  • New efficiency standards make replacement cost-effective

Damage That Can't Be Fixed

Multiple leak points: When you're looking at 3+ separate leak repairs, replacement makes financial sense. Each repair costs $75-150, and you're still left with an aging system.

Significant sagging: Sagging more than 2 inches indicates:

  • Structural fastener failure
  • Gutter material fatigue
  • Potential fascia board damage
  • Water pooling that creates mosquito breeding grounds (big issue in Jacksonville)

Foundation water damage: If you're seeing:

  • Soil erosion around foundation
  • Basement or crawl space water intrusion
  • Foundation settling or cracking
  • Landscape damage from overflow

The gutter system has failed its primary purpose. Repairs won't address the underlying capacity or structural issues.

Fascia board damage: Water damage behind gutters often means:

  • Rotted or soft fascia boards
  • Roof decking damage
  • Potential mold issues in Florida's humidity
  • Pest entry points

Replacement allows addressing these issues properly during installation.

Material Options and Costs

Aluminum: The Florida Standard

Why aluminum dominates in Florida:

  • Excellent corrosion resistance in salt air
  • Lightweight reduces structural load
  • Available in 20+ colors to match your home
  • Cost-effective for most budgets
  • Handles thermal expansion well

Aluminum costs in Jacksonville (2026):

  • Standard 5" K-style: $4-6 per linear foot installed
  • 6" K-style for heavy rains: $5-7 per linear foot installed
  • Premium seamless with lifetime warranty: $6-8 per linear foot installed
  • Average home (150 linear feet): $600-$1,200

Aluminum limitations:

  • Can dent from hail or falling branches
  • Not as elegant as copper for historic homes
  • Limited to about 35-foot seamless sections

Copper: Premium Performance

Why choose copper in Florida:

  • Develops protective patina that resists salt air indefinitely
  • Elegant appearance increases home value
  • Can be soldered for permanent, leak-proof joints
  • Handles hurricane-force winds better than aluminum

Copper costs in Jacksonville (2026):

  • Standard 5" half-round: $15-20 per linear foot installed
  • 6" K-style commercial grade: $18-25 per linear foot installed
  • Custom profiles and soldered joints: $20-30 per linear foot installed
  • Average home (150 linear feet): $2,250-$4,500

Copper considerations:

  • Requires specialized installation skills
  • Initial bright copper appearance changes to green patina over 5-10 years
  • Theft risk in some neighborhoods
  • May require special downspout protection

Vinyl: Budget Option with Limitations

Vinyl pros:

  • Lowest upfront cost: $2-4 per linear foot installed
  • Never rusts or corrodes
  • Easy DIY installation for handy homeowners
  • Available in basic colors

Why we rarely recommend vinyl in Florida:

  • Becomes brittle in UV exposure (major issue here)
  • Limited wind resistance for hurricane season
  • Expansion joints fail in temperature cycles
  • Color fading in intense sun
  • Difficult to repair when damaged

Better alternatives: For budget-conscious homeowners, entry-level aluminum provides much better long-term value than vinyl.

Steel: Heavy Duty for Specific Applications

When steel makes sense:

  • Commercial or industrial buildings
  • Areas with extreme hail risk
  • Historic restorations requiring specific profiles
  • Homes with oversized roof areas

Steel challenges in Florida:

  • Corrosion requires galvanized or stainless grades
  • Heavier weight may require structural modifications
  • Limited color options
  • Higher installation costs: $8-15 per linear foot

Florida Building Code Requirements

Wind Load Standards

Current Florida requirements (2026):

  • Coastal areas (within 1 mile of water): 180 mph wind rating minimum
  • Inland areas: 150 mph wind rating minimum
  • All gutters must be engineered for uplift resistance
  • Fasteners must penetrate structural members, not just sheathing

What this means for replacement:

  • Gutter hangers every 18-24 inches maximum
  • Specific screw types and lengths required
  • End caps and joints must meet wind rating standards
  • Professional installation required for code compliance

Corrosion Resistance

Salt air requirements:

  • All fasteners must be stainless steel or hot-dip galvanized
  • Aluminum gutters require marine-grade coatings
  • Dissimilar metal connections need proper isolation
  • Warranty requirements for coastal installations

Drainage Calculations

Florida's high rainfall requirements:

  • Standard 5" gutters handle up to 2,500 sq ft of roof
  • 6" gutters required for larger roof areas
  • Downspout sizing: 1 sq inch per 100 sq ft of roof
  • Overflow provisions required for extreme weather events

Cost Breakdown: Total Project Investment

Basic Aluminum Replacement (150 ft home)

Materials:

  • Seamless aluminum gutters: $300-450
  • Downspouts and elbows: $150-250
  • Hangers and fasteners: $75-125
  • End caps and accessories: $50-100
  • Total materials: $575-925

Labor and installation:

  • Removal of old gutters: $200-350
  • Installation of new system: $400-600
  • Cleanup and disposal: $100-150
  • Total labor: $700-1,100

Total project cost: $1,275-2,025

Premium Copper Installation (150 ft home)

Materials:

  • Copper gutters and fittings: $1,500-2,250
  • Copper downspouts: $450-675
  • Soldering materials and brackets: $200-300
  • Total materials: $2,150-3,225

Specialized labor:

  • Old system removal: $200-350
  • Copper installation and soldering: $800-1,200
  • Custom fitting and finishing: $300-450
  • Total labor: $1,300-2,000

Total project cost: $3,450-5,225

Hidden Costs to Budget For

Fascia board repairs:

  • Minor repairs: $200-500
  • Partial replacement: $500-1,200
  • Complete fascia replacement: $1,200-2,500

Roof edge work:

  • Drip edge installation: $3-5 per linear foot
  • Soffit repairs: $8-15 per linear foot
  • Rafter tail repairs: $50-150 per repair

Permit and inspection fees:

  • Building permit: $75-200
  • Required inspections: $100-300
  • Engineering stamping (if required): $200-500

Timing Your Replacement

Best Season for Gutter Work in Florida

Optimal timing: October through February

  • Lower humidity for material handling
  • Fewer afternoon thunderstorms
  • Cooler working conditions for installers
  • Hurricane season has ended

Avoid these times:

  • March-May: Heavy pollen season clogs new systems immediately
  • June-November: Hurricane season makes scheduling unpredictable
  • Peak summer: Extreme heat affects installation quality

Hurricane Season Considerations

Pre-season replacement (March-May):

  • Higher demand increases prices 10-20%
  • Contractor availability becomes limited
  • Material delivery delays common
  • Rush jobs may sacrifice quality

Post-storm replacement:

  • Insurance claims may cover costs
  • Contractor availability extremely limited
  • Material costs increase dramatically
  • Temporary fixes may be necessary

Best strategy: Plan replacement during calm weather, complete by May 1st.

Making the Repair vs Replace Decision

The 50% Rule

If repair costs exceed 50% of replacement cost, replace.

Example: Your 15-year-old gutters need $800 in repairs, but replacement costs $1,600. Replace - you'll get a new system with warranty for twice the repair cost.

The Age Factor

Gutter age guidelines:

  • Under 10 years: Repair unless extensive damage
  • 10-20 years: Evaluate based on overall condition and future plans
  • Over 20 years: Replace - repairs are just delaying the inevitable

The Damage Assessment

Professional evaluation criteria:

  • Number of separate problem areas
  • Structural integrity of fastening system
  • Condition of fascia boards and roof edge
  • Water damage evidence around foundation

Getting Professional Assessment

What to Expect from Evaluation

Comprehensive inspection includes:

  • Complete gutter system measurement
  • Assessment of pitch and drainage
  • Fascia board and roof edge condition check
  • Downspout capacity evaluation
  • Foundation area inspection for water damage

Red flags in contractor evaluations:

  • Pressure to decide immediately
  • Estimates without getting on ladder to inspect
  • Prices significantly below or above market rates
  • No discussion of permit requirements
  • Unwillingness to provide local references

Questions to Ask Contractors

About the work:

  1. What specific problems do you see with my current system?
  2. How do you determine proper gutter sizing for Florida rainfall?
  3. What wind rating do your installations meet?
  4. How do you handle fascia board repairs if needed?

About the business:

  1. Are you licensed for gutter work in Florida?
  2. Do you carry general liability and workers compensation insurance?
  3. How do you handle storm damage call-backs?
  4. What does your warranty cover, and for how long?

Conclusion

The repair versus replace decision comes down to economics and timing. Older gutters with multiple problems will cost more to patch than replace, and you'll still have an aging system vulnerable to failure.

Florida's challenging weather conditions - from hurricanes to salt air to intense UV - make this decision even more critical. A properly installed new gutter system not only protects your home better but often qualifies for insurance discounts and adds to property value.

The key is getting professional assessment before problems become expensive emergencies. Water damage to foundations, landscaping, and structural components costs far more than gutter replacement.

Ready for a professional assessment? We provide honest evaluations of repair versus replacement options, with transparent pricing and Florida building code compliance guaranteed. Get your free estimate at get your free estimate or call (888) 507-4854.

Don't wait for the next hurricane season to find out your gutters can't handle the job.